Born October 27,
1901, Wynnewood OK
Died November 7, 1962, Washington, D.C.
Herndon
Davis was born into the transitional West. He spent the next 61 years living large,
a product of his times and an influence on them. During the first half of the
twentieth century, the American West was in flux, still highly romanticized, even
mythic in the popular imagination, but simultaneously struggling to function as
a modern economic force. While Davis personal history reflects that larger
struggle, his style of presenting his personal history guaranteed a colorful tale,
Dickensian in scope and scale, amorphous in date and detail, romantic, even mythic.
For Davis, the facts never got in the way of a good story.
Oklahoma
was still Indian Territory when Davis was born there. His grandfather claimed
a first-cousinship to Confederate President Jefferson Davis, but that didnt
lend much luster to the familys circumstances. His parents are described
as both ranchers and farmers; in either role, they moved
repeatedly, thirteen times in as many years. Within this nomadic existence, Davis
started sketching as a toddler. Although the artist later claimed
he could plow a pretty good furrow, he also hated milking cows. He
left home at fourteen.
Davis headed for Kansas City,
Missouri, shining shoes to earn money for his first art lessons. He surfaced later
in Chicago, where he served as an engravers apprentice and worked as a commercial
artist for Armour & Company. Sometime later he was harvesting fields to fund a
short stint at William Jewell College in Liberty, Kansas. Davis first saw Denver
in 1920 as a U.S. Army private; troops were stationed here to keep the peace during
a streetcar workers strike. Davis served three hitches in the army, where
his art aptitude was recognized and fostered. Stationed back in Washington, D.C.,
Davis attended the War College (working as a draftsman on secret military maps
of Japan and China) and, briefly, the Corcoran School of Fine Art. Davis had great
facility for capturing character in the human face, and his gregarious nature
helped bring portrait commissions from the high-ranking military personnel who
were also his drinking buddies. Sometime in the 1920s he studied at Yale (again,
briefly), working as a restaurant cashier at the old Taft Hotel Grill to finance
his studies.
By the mid-1920s Davis was in New York
City, living in Greenwich Village. He later cited stints at the Art Students League
and the National Academy during this period. In his own picaresque version of
events, he earned food money by drawing pastels of burlesque queens. For better
money (if not better story-telling), Davis also did vast quantities of commercial
illustration. During these years, his crosshatched drawings appeared in the New
York Herald-Tribune, the Washington Times-Herald, and the Washington
Daily News (where he worked with Ernie Pyle), as well as Forum and
McClures magazines. In 1929 he met Edna Juanita Cotter, another artist
in his Greenwich Village apartment building. Nita was a British subject
from Jamaica, eleven years Davis senior and, soon, his wife.
The
chronology gets tangled again but according to Davis much-later Denver
Post account, he came to Denver in 1936 (apparently with Nita) to visit his
mother. That is a polite way of saying that an unemployed newspaper artist
from Washington D.C. came home to eat, he demurred. Davis vintage
first-person version of The Face on the Barroom Floor followed:
The
Central City Opera House Association hired me to do a series of paintings and
sketches of the famous mining town, which they were then rejuvenating as an opera
center and tourist attraction. I stayed at the Teller House while working up there,
and the whim struck me to paint a face on the floor of the old Teller House barroom.
In its mining boom heyday it was just such a floor as the ragged artist [used?]
in H. Antoine dArcy's famous old poem. But the hotel manager and the bartender
would have none of such tomfoolery. They refused me permission to paint the face.
Still the idea haunted me, and in my last night in Central City, I persuaded the
bellboy Jimmy Libby to give me a hand. After midnight, when the coast was clear,
we slipped down there. Jimmy held a candle for me and I painted as fast as I could.
Yet it was 3 AM when I finished. By the dawns early light I lit out for
Denver.*
Some other pertinent details: The floor-painting
option probably wasnt proposed, discussed or refused before it was executed.
Herndon Davis had had a furious argument that day with Ann Evans, director of
the restoration project. The artist who once sketched burlesque queens had opted
for grimly realistic depictions of the gunslingers, gamblers, hookers and struggling
miners who predated the Opera House Associations white-gloved interest in
the small town. Evans, granddaughter of former Colorado territorial Governor John
Evans and nicknamed the Duchess of Denver society, insisted he delete
the gritty detail. Whether Davis quit or was fired during the fracas isnt
certain, but either way he was out of the job. Bellboy Jimmy Libby (who may actually
have been a busboy named Joe) egged Davis on, saying, Youre finished
here anyway. Why not give them something to remember you by?*
Davis
didnt start work immediately. While the sixteen-year-old Libby sanded the
floor varnish off with a rough brick, the artist got primed on Cuba Libres. Once
lubricated, he painted Nitas face, and lit out for Denver, claiming
later hed feared having to clean the floor if he lingered. He also faced
trouble back in town. Nita wouldnt be happy about the lost job, and she
proved to be even more unhappy to learn that her own distinctive features were
decorating the floor of a bar. How quickly she found out about The Face
remains a mystery.
As it turned out, the hotel management
loved the painting and quickly supplied two semi-overlapping stories to explain
its existence. The first was that the painting was the impetus for the sentimental
H. Antoine dArcy poem about a dying vagabond-cowboy painting his sweethearts
image (conversely, Davis cited the schmaltzy poem as his own inspiration in his
1954 Denver Post account). The second and truer explanation: a drunk painted
The Face. Certainly the artist was drunk at the time. If Davis signed his
work the night he painted it, the signature soon went missing, which added romantic
mystery as the quaintly pretty visage started attracting sightseers.
In
1937, Davis (again, with or without Nita?) headed for Puerto Rica, where he found
work as art director of El Imparcial, a San Juan newspaper. The job soon ended
when the papers offices were bombed. Davis emerged unscathed and by February
1938, his Puerto Rican Sketches in Gouache were on exhibit in the
Denver Art Museums Chappell House at 1300 Logan Street. Whether Davis came
back to Denver with his artwork isnt clear, but his mother was apparently
still living here, and Davis and Nita owned a home at 1323 Kalamath.
Davis
later claimed that after painting The Face, he didnt return to Denver
until 1946 and then was stunned at its fame and irate because he wasnt receiving
credit. He told of going up to Central City in 1946 and signing the now-renowned
artwork, but claimed that in the interests of romantic mystery and tourism, the
signature was removed as soon as he left the building. Perhaps at Nitas
own insistence, Davis never credited her as his inspiration, saying instead, It
was just a face… If it happens to look like some one, it is just a happenstance.
However, when two Denver buddies tried to commission him to paint identical faces
in their homes, Davis refused, offering to paint floor-portraits of their own
wives rather than his. Both men maintained the secret of The Faces
identity until after Davis death.
Davis lived
in Denver for many of his remaining years, working as illustrator at both the
Denver Post and the Rocky Mountain News, sometimes simultaneously.
This had to be a major juggling act, since the afternoon broadsheet Post
and the morning tabloid News were locked in a long, bitter and often ugly
feud for journalistic dominance. His column-and-illustration combo, Once
Upon a Time, appeared in the Post with tales of the old west; his
society sketches of the contemporary west appeared in the Sunday News.
Art remained only one of his trades: he worked doing layout for printing shops
as well. Downtown Denver suited Davis. He had alley-shortcuts to many of the saloons
then lining the streets, often swapping portrait work to clear his outstanding
bar tabs. For example, at the Keg, he painted the owners likeness on a barstool
seat: Now everyone can sit on my face, said that delighted recipient.

The
history of the west fascinated Davis and he recorded his visions of it both visually
and verbally. A series of watercolor paintings of unique area buildings became
one of Davis means to explore local and regional history, of which he had
a rich understanding. Besides his continuing illustration work, many other activities
occupied the artist over the years. Davis received a White House commission for
a portrait of Eisenhower (who had ties to Denver through his wife Mamie). At the
old Meiningers art supply store, many of the artists portraits painted
on palettes were done by Davis. He also had mural work all over the city: at the
tearoom of the Denver Dry Goods store, in a basement amusement room
for attorney-pal Fred M. Mazzulla; at Denvers old Juvenile Hall (Americans
Who Have Triumphed Over Childhood Adversity) and in the Denver Press Club,
among other locations.
In 1962, Herndon Davis was
back in Washington D.C. working on plans for a massive mural for the Smithsonian
Institute when he suffered a fatal heart attack. Hes buried at Fort Logan
National Cemetery in Denver. Nita Davis died in 1975, triggering a retelling of
the story behind The Face on the Barroom Floor, which still generates enough
interest to be revisited in the Denver and Colorado press every five years or
so.
PARTIAL BIBLIOGRAPHY:
Rocky Mountain Life,
vol. 1, #5, August 1946, p. 18
Denver Post, September 4, 1949, magazine
section p. 1
*Denver Post, December 19, 1954, p. 6aa
Denver
Post, May 27, 1956, p. 9+
Denver Post, February 18, 1957
Denver
Post, February 3, 1961, p. 64
Denver Post, November 8, 1962, p.
1
Denver Post, October 8, 1967, p. 26
Rocky Mountain News,
November 4, 1975, pp. 5 & 13, p. 15
Denver Post, November 4, 1975,
p. 15
Rocky Mountain News, August 24, 1986, p. 25
Rocky Mountain
News, August 22, 1993, magazine section, p.5
Rocky Mountain News,
November 28, 1993, magazine section, p. 13